Donald Trump set off a firestorm of criticism over the weekend with a tweet.
It’d seem to be nothing new, however critics say the President’s current submit is greater than offensive—they are saying it’s dictatorial.
“He who saves his Nation doesn’t violate any Legislation,” Trump posted on his social media website Fact Social in addition to on Elon Musk’s X platform (previously Twitter) on Saturday. The White Home account on X additionally shared the message alongside Trump’s official presidential {photograph}.
A model of the phrase is commonly attributed to Napoleon Bonaparte, the French normal who topped himself emperor in 1804 and was identified for his authoritarian rule—and whom Trump has quoted earlier than.
Trump’s newest Napoleonic comment has rankled Democrats and liberal commentators. Sen. Adam Schiff (D., Calif.) responded to Trump on X: “Spoken like a real dictator.” New York Occasions columnist Jamelle Bouie described it as “the only most un-american and anti-constitutional assertion ever uttered by an american president” on social media platform Bluesky.
Some anti-Trump conservatives have additionally voiced their unease. Anthony Scaramucci, who briefly served as White Home communications director throughout Trump’s first time period earlier than changing into a vocal intraparty critic, reposted Trump’s assertion, including: “Desires to be a dictator. In the event you don’t see it it means you don’t need to.”
Former Vice President Mike Pence appeared to implicitly rebuke Trump’s submit by resharing an essay he’d written in 2010, titled “The Presidency and the Structure,” during which he wrote: “A president who slights the Structure is sort of a rider who hates his horse: he shall be thrown, and the nation together with him. The president solemnly swears to protect, shield, and defend the Structure. He doesn’t solemnly swear to disregard, overlook, complement, or reinterpret it.”
Dan McLaughlin, a senior author on the Nationwide Evaluation who wrote in November about writing in Pence for the 2024 election, posted on X about Trump’s declaration: “That is some un-American monarchical nonsense. The president is above *some* legal guidelines, as a result of there are issues legally solely he could do. However his whole workplace stays a creature of regulation.”
Invoice Kristol, former chief of workers to Vice President Dan Quayle and a distinguished Trump critic, posted on Bluesky, “We’re stepping into actual Führerprinzip territory right here”—referencing the Nazi Germany precept that Führer Adolf Hitler’s phrase was above the regulation.
Billy Binion, a reporter for libertarian journal Cause, posted on X: “I do know many conservatives nonetheless care in regards to the Structure. However it’s genuinely miserable that the chief of the Republican Celebration is somebody who’s brazenly OK with violating the rule of regulation so long as it serves his political ends. That’s…dangerous. I miss actual conservatism.”
Former RNC Chair Reince Priebus, Trump’s first chief of workers throughout his first time period, dismissed the criticisms of Trump’s submit, excusing the provocative assertion as mere trolling and “catnip for the media.”
“It’s leisure for Trump. It’s a distraction,” Priebus stated on ABC Information’ This Week on Sunday. “That is what the President does.”
A few of Trump’s supporters, nevertheless, have welcomed the Napoleonic declaration. “Thanks, President Trump. We love you,” controversial right-wing activist Laura Loomer responded to Trump’s submit on X.
Musk, who heads the Division of Authorities Effectivity, reposted Trump’s message on X, appending 14 U.S. flag emojis.
And right-wing commentator Jack Posobiec additionally shared Trump’s message, including “America shall be saved” and “What should be completed shall be completed.”
Learn Extra: Donald Trump Retains Teasing a Third Time period. Right here’s What to Know
It’s not the primary time Trump or his allies have instructed that the rule of regulation mustn’t get in the best way of his agenda. Because the Trump Administration already faces dozens of lawsuits, Vice President J.D. Vance posted on X on Feb. 9 that “judges aren’t allowed to regulate the chief’s reputable energy.”
White Home Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt additionally beforehand accused the media of “fearmongering” a few “constitutional disaster,” saying throughout a information briefing on Feb. 12: “The true constitutional disaster is happening inside our judicial department, the place district court docket judges in liberal districts throughout the nation are abusing their energy to unilaterally block President Trump’s primary government authority.”
The Structure, nevertheless, established the three separate branches of presidency (government, legislative, and judicial) particularly to behave as a system of checks and balances—with the courts, particularly, empowered to rule on the constitutionality of legal guidelines and presidential actions.
As for the Supreme Court docket’s ruling on presidential immunity final 12 months, it stipulated that Presidents have absolute immunity from prison prosecution for actions taken inside their “constitutional authority” and presumptive immunity for different official acts, however that: “The President enjoys no immunity for his unofficial acts, and never all the pieces the President does is official. The President shouldn’t be above the regulation.”
